history of loch broom
The Loch Broom Yair Riot 1832
Introduction
At the head of Loch Broom at low tide, one can see a stone structure in the sea in the shape of an ‘L’. It was a yair, or cairidh as described in Gaelic. It was used for catching fish, especially salmon and herring. The fish would swim past it at high tide and when the water receded, they would be caught between the walls at low tide. But what was its history? Who built it and why? And what can it tell us about the history of the district?
Content
History
Although there are not many primary sources about the cairidh, if one visits the website “Tobar an Dualchais”, one can find an interesting interview with John MacLennan. He was born in 1886 and was raised in Letters, Loch Broom. He was a tradition bearer and was a great source of local history and lore. Researchers from the School of Scottish Studies made 25 recordings of him and his wife Anne in the 1960s, the majority of which were in Gaelic. In 1961, he gave an interview about the origins of the cairidh (MacLennan, 1961).
A new minister came to the parish of Lochbroom in 1808. (Macleod 2011:69) His name was the Reverend Dr. Thomas Ross, and he was an interesting and educated man. He was one of the foremost Gaelic scholars of his day and he could speak five languages. He translated the bible into Gaelic and was the father of 14 children. (Iredale 2008:101). One can still read his contemporary account of the parish of Lochbroom from the 1830s in the “New Statistical Account” (Ross 1845).
It was the time of the Highland Clearances, and people were being displaced from their traditional lands throughout the district. The church had a landholding at the head of Loch Broom, and the Rev. Dr. Ross created new crofts on part of it (Ross 1845). The land was rough and steep (Letters comes from the Gaelic “An Leitir” meaning steep place). According to John MacLennan, the people who settled in Letters had to work for the minister, as the church was all-powerful at that time. And with that, the cairidh was built by the local people in 1818 (Iredale 2008:103) and every fish caught in it would be the property of the minister.
Also in 1818, Norman Macleod from Assynt applied to be the teacher in the parish school in Ullapool, but Rev. Dr. Ross refused his application and because of this, Macleod emigrated to Canada (Iredale 2008:104). With that, one can see the unintended influence that Ross had on Gaelic and the Gaels both in Canada and New Zealand, even to this day, given the influence of MacLeod in setting up immigrant Gaelic communities first in Canada and subsequently in New Zealand in the 19th century.
The Herring Fishery
Fishing was extremely important to Loch Broom through the centuries. In the 1780s, the British Fisheries Society was looking for a site to establish a new planned village and they chose Ullapool. New buildings were built in support of the herring fishery and in that manner, the “new” village of Ullapool was established in 1788. (Macleod 2011:58). Although the venture was successful at first, the herring did not appear reliably each season and the fishermen grew poor at the start of the 19th Century. (Munro 1994:266).
The Church Cairidh in the 1820s
The new cairidh was highly effective and a great many herring were caught in it. It was reported that in 1823, Rev. Dr. Ross was selling herring that had been caught in his cairidh. (MacGregor 2020). The Ullapool fishermen were not too successful at this time and there was a great deal of resentment towards Rev. Dr. Ross. The fishermen’s nets had to be a certain size to allow smaller fish to swim free, but the cairidh would catch any fish, large or small. The British Fishery Society were unhappy about this as reported in the press at the time (Dunsmure 1829).
In March 1832, there were reports in the newspapers about typhoid in the district, and how a great many herring had been left to rot in the cairidh. Some were of the option that this was the reason why there was sickness and ill-health in the locality (it was the time of cholera and heightened concerns of such matters). (Inverness Courier 1832).

WEDNESDAY, MARCH 7, 1832
The letter on cholera from Ross-shire did not reach us till Thursday morning, a day too late for our last publication. It would now be unnecessary to publish it, as the Quarter Session was held yesterday at Dingwall.
We have received two other letters on the subject of cholera from Ross-shire. One is from Lochcarron; the other deprecates the precipitancy of Dr Ross in writing to the Board of Health, thereby causing great unnecessary alarm; and states that in the cases of typhus that have appeared in Lochbroom and the neighbouring parishes, it was not till the ninth or tenth day that the disease assumed appearances, which might be thought to resemble cholera.
“The vast quantities of herrings and other fish,” says our correspondent, “which were allowed to rot on the shores last season, must have vitiated the air, and the poor people were obliged, for want of salt, to hang their winter supply to then roofs of their houses, to preserve them, if possible in the smoke. This circumstance may perhaps throw some light on the subject, and help to explain to Dr Ross why his neighbourhood is ravaged with typhus”.
The situation came to a head in September 1832, when around 200 people descended on the cairidh, Ullapool fishermen in their midst, and they destroyed it and a similar structure on the other side of the loch belonging to a neighbouring landowner.
The Dundonnell Cause
Near Clachan, over the hill and connected by a well-worn path, there is an estate mansion house called Dundonnell. Dundonnell Estate marched with the Glebe lands. The Rev. Dr Doss was married to Jane MacKenzie, sister of the laird, Kenneth MacKenzie. MacKenzie was a peculiar man, (Iredale 2008:105), but he died in 1821 and a controversy grew when it was revealed that his lawyer, Robert Roy, was to inherit the estate. It was thought that there was foul play afoot and the population of the strath were very unhappy. There were a series of events between 1826 and 1828 where cattle were killed and damage was done to the estate house seemingly by unknown individuals opposed to Robert Roy. Rev Dr Ross and his wife had a personal and financial interest in the outcome of whoever would inherit the estate. (Iredale 2008:121).
“Atrocities in Ross-shire”
In June 1833, the Edinburgh-based newspaper “Caledonian Mercury” published a sensational and feverish article under the headline “Horrible Atrocities in Ross-shire (Caledonian Mercury 1833). The story tried to make a link between the contemporary land struggle in Ireland and the happenings in Dundonnell and with the cairidh in order to prove that Loch Broom was a lawless and chaotic district.

HORRIBLE ATROCITIES IN ROSS-SHIRE
The atrocities which have from time to time been committed in Ross-shire – and we are ashamed to say, in every case with perfect impunity – exceed all belief, and if paralleled, are certainly not surpassed, by some of the worst deeds done in some of the worst parts of Ireland.
In the month of September 1832, a yair, the property of Sir George Mackenzie of Coul, Baronet, and another belonging to the Reverend Dr Ross of Lochbroom, were demolished, in broad day, by a mob of about a hundred lawless ruffians, armed with hatchets, who went about their work with perfect deliberation, and when one of Dr Ross’s sons attempted to interpose for the protection of his father’s property, they threatened to hew him in pieces with their axes if he dared to offer the least resistance.
It has reported that a lawless and armed rabble descended on the cairidh and destroyed it. The language deployed in the story was scathing and disrespectful of the Gaels and natives of Loch Broom. The story was republished in multiple newspapers throughout the United Kingdom and also in Ireland, where the land question was extremely controversial at the time. The Carlisle Journal even commented that perhaps there should be a “Scotch Coercion Bill”, similar to the tactics deployed in Ireland by the ruling classes.

The very thought of such monstrous and unheard-of cruelty makes one’s blood run cold. – Why don’t the Ministers bring in a Scotch coercion bill?
A reply to the original article was published in the Caledonian Mercury on 19th June 1833 under the pen name “M.M.M.G”, in which the claims were repudiated, and the local populace defended (M.M.M.G. 1833). It was reported that the letter was written by four local landowners (Caledonian Mercury 1833). It was suspected that Rev. Dr. Ross himself, or someone close to him, had written the original story that had caused such controversy. (Bangor-Jones 1994:106).
The case reached the office of the Home Secretary in London, Lord Melbourne, and he ordered an investigation into the affair. (Iredale 2008:115). His conclusion was published in The Globe (a contemporary London newspaper) on 22nd June 1833. It was concluded that the report in the Caledonian Mercury concerning the destruction of the cairidh and the other local upheavals were grossly exaggerated. (Globe 1833).

We are authorised to mention, that in consequence of a statement having appeared in the Caledonian Mercury of the 3rd inst., under the title of “Horrible Atrocities in Ross-shire”, describing outrages said to have been committed in the district of Lochbroom in last September, and still worse outrages said to have been committed very recently in the same district, a strict inquiry has been made into the facts, and it has been ascertained that the account as to the outrage in September is grossly exaggerated, and that as to the supposed recent outrage is entirely false.
Despite this, Rev Dr Ross continued to write a series of somewhat hysterical and haughty letters to the newspapers over the summer of 1833 in a style very much reminiscent of the original report in the Caledonian Mercury. (Ross 1833). Eventually, three Ullapool fishermen appeared in the court in Inverness on charges relating to the destruction of the cairidh (six others similarly charged were absent as they were engaged in the herring fishing in Sutherland). The defendants admitted that they had destroyed the cairidh but claimed htat there were mitigating circumstances. Sentences were handed down – two months’ detention in the jailhouse in Tain.

MALICIOUS MISCHIEF – FISHING YAIRS
ALEXANDER MATHESON, DONALD MACKENZIE, RODERICK MACGREGOR, ALLAN CAMPBELL, MURDO URQUHART, COLIN MACLEOD, AND JOHN CAMERON, alias CASTLE, NORMAN MACLEOD, and COLIN ROSS, all fish men, residing in Ullapool, parish of Lochbroom, were indicted for having on the 14th September 1832, “maliciously, wantonly, feloniously, and mischievously, destroying the yair for catching salmon, or herrings, or other fishes, situated on or near the shore of that part of Lochbroom, near Inverlael, parish of Lochbroom, belonging to Sir G.S. Mackenzie of Coul, Bart”. Also, at the same time the parties were charged with breaking a yair at the mouth of the river Beroom, near the glebe lands of the parish, the property of the Rev. Dr Thomas Ross, minister of Lochbroom. Three of the accused, viz. – Allan Campbell, Norman Macleod, and Colin Ross, answered to their names, and were placed at the bar, while the remainder were outlawed for non-appearance.
In this case, the name of Mr Donald Fraser, agent for the British Society for the encouragement of Fisheries, and residing in Ullapool, was included. Mr Fraser had engaged and instructed counsel to defend him, and he was present in Court; but the Crown Advocate-Depute stated that his name had been introduced into the indictment erroneously, as there was no ground for a case against him, and the indictment, as far as he was concerned, was abandoned. The reason of the non-appearance and outlawry of the other persons for the destruction of the yairs, was their being in Caithness at the herring fishing, when the citations were served at their dwellings.
The three prisoners at the bar pleaded guilty to the charge.
Charles Neave , Esq. Advocate, addressed the Court in explanation of the circumstances of the case. He would not enter into the question as to the legality or the illegality of yairs, but it was certain that in the present instance they had been productive of great loss to the poor fishermen. When the cholera appeared in this country, and was daily expected in Lochbroom, the putrid fish left by the yairs were supposed to be fraught with contagion, and under this impression, with want staring them in the face, the men had risen in a body and committed the offence libelled. Nothing could justify lawless violence, but he hoped the court would take these circumstances into consideration in awarding punishment. Mr Neave also produced a highly favourable certificate as to character, on behalf of a clergyman of the parish.
Sir George Mackenzie begged to address the Court for a moment. Being a sufferer by the misconduct of the prisoners, he was desirous of stating that he was convinced the men were entirely misled, and that he would be highly gratified by the Court passing as lenient a sentence as possible. Sir George, on sitting down, was cheered by the audience.
Lord Meadowbank admonished the prisoners on the illegality of their conduct. He trusted that their case would be a warning to others to deter them from committing the like crime. His Lordship then sentenced the men to two months imprisonment in the jail of Tain, and to find security of £10 each, to keep the peace for three years, or in default of their doing so, to be imprisoned for two months longer.
A character reference on behalf of the fishermen was submitted to the court with a plea for clemency by a local cleric – but this was not Rev. Dr. Ross – the plea came from Rev. Alexander Ross of Ullapool. (Inverness Courier 1833).
Conclusion
It is an interesting case, concerning the problems facing the Highlands at the start of the 19th Century. It was a time of upheaval. Poverty was widespread. We can see the power of the church, and that there was a close link between the church and the landowning classes. We can see the disparaging attitudes held by southern newspapers against the Gaels, whom they viewed as savages. Although he himself was a Gael, it is clear from his correspondence that Ross considered the attack on the cairidh as an attack on the authority of the church and him as the parish minister and he obviously hoped for stiff retribution to be handed out to the culprits. It is interesting that the case reached the highest strata of government in London, despite the fact that Loch Broom was very much remote from the major population centres of the south at that time.
The pattern of landownership in the area that was established in the early 19th century is still with us today.
Postscript
The cairidh was rebuilt, but on a much smaller scale, and it went out of use at the end of the 19th century.
At the time of the Great Disruption in 1843, Rev Dr Ross decided to break with the established church but he died in July of the same year at the age of seventy four at Clachan Manse, from which he was in the process of being removed due to his decision to follow the new church (Macleod 2011:83).
And to this day, the church retains land ownership and salmon fishing rights at the head of Loch Broom. The doors of the church closed for the last time as a place of worship in November 2016. However, Clachan Church was acquired by the community in 2018 and it will be used as a community asset in the coming years. (BBC 2018).

And today, if one walks down the steep bank of An Leitir to the cairidh, there is nothing to be found but mussel-covered stones, seaweed and the ghosts of history.

References
Bangor-Jones, M (1994), “MacKenzie Families of the Barony of Lochbroom” in Peoples & Settlement in North-West Ross ed. by Baldwin, J, Dùn Èideann: The Scottish Society for Northern Studies
BBC News (2018), “Offer Accepted for Historic Clachan Lochbroom Church”, BBC News 13 Giblean 2018 [air loidhne] ri fhaotainn bho https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-highlands-islands-43752035 [22 Giblean 2021]
Caledonian Mercury (1833) “Horrible Atrocities in Ross-shire” 3 Ògmhios 1833 p 3, British Newspaper Archive, [air loidhne] ri fhaotainn bho https://www-britishnewspaperarchive-co-uk.nls.idm.oclc.org/viewer/bl/0000045/18330603/010/0003 [22 Giblean 2021]
Caledonian Mercury (1833) “The Globe and its Authority”, 27 Ògmhios 1833 p 3, British Newspaper Archive [air loidhne] ri fhaotainn bho https://www-britishnewspaperarchive-co-uk.nls.idm.oclc.org/viewer/BL/0000045/18330627/006/0003#
Carlisle Journal (1833) “Miscellany”, 15 Ògmhios 1833 p 4, British Newspaper Archive, [air loidhne] ri fhaotainn bho https://www-britishnewspaperarchive-co-uk.nls.idm.oclc.org/viewer/bl/0000363/18330615/019/0004 [22 Giblean 2021]
Dunsmure, T (1829) “Office of the Herring Fishery Edinburgh, Edinburgh, 28th January 1829”, Inverness Courier 10 Iuchar 1833, p 3, British Newspaper Archive, [air loidhne] ri fhaotainn bho https://www-britishnewspaperarchive-co-uk.nls.idm.oclc.org/viewer/BL/0000446/18330710/039/0003?browse=true [22 Giblean 2021]
Inverness Courier (1832) “Wednesday March 7 1832”, 7 Mart 1832 p 2 British Newspaper Archive, [air loidhne] ri fhaotainn bho https://www-britishnewspaperarchive-co-uk.nls.idm.oclc.org/viewer/BL/0000446/18320307/008/0002 [22 Giblean 2021]
Inverness Courier (1833) “Malicious Mischief – Fishing Yairs”, 11 Sultain 1833 p 3, British Newspaper Archive, [air loidhne] ri fhaotainn bho https://www-britishnewspaperarchive-co-uk.nls.idm.oclc.org/viewer/BL/0000446/18330911/026/0003?browse=False [22 Giblean 2021]
Iredale, D (2008), “Dundonnell of the MacKenzies”, Chichester: Phillimore
MacGregor, J (2020), “Scoraig – A Peninsula and its People”, Alba: JRM Publishing
MacLennan, J (1961), “Family History and Fish Weirs”, agallamh le Dr Iain MacAonghais agus Iain Crawford, 24 Cèitean 1961, Sgoil Eòlais na h-Alba, [air loidhne] ri fhaotainn bho http://www.tobarandualchais.co.uk/en/fullrecord/81627?backURL=/en/search%3Fpage%3D1%23track_81627 [15 Giblean 2021]
Macleod, K (2011), “Lochbroom Through the Centuries”, Inbhir Nis: Ardvreck
M.M.M.G. (1833), “Calumnies Against Ross-shire”, Caledonian Mercury 24 Ògmhios 1833 p 4, British Newspaper Archive, [air loidhne] ri fhaotainn bho https://www-britishnewspaperarchive-co-uk.nls.idm.oclc.org/viewer/bl/0000045/18330624/018/0004 [22 Giblean 2021]
Munro, J (1994), “Ullapool and the British Fisheries Society” in Peoples & Settlement in North-West Ross ed. by Baldwin, J, Dùn Èideann: The Scottish Society for Northern Studies
Ross, T, (1833) “To the Editor of the Inverness Courier”, Inverness Courier 10 Iuchar 1833 p 3, British Newspaper Archive, [air loidhne] ri fhaotainn bho https://www-britishnewspaperarchive-co-uk.nls.idm.oclc.org/viewer/BL/0000446/18330710/039/0003?browse=true [22 Giblean 2021]
Ross, T (1845), “Lochbroom County of Ross and Cromarty”, New Statistical Account, Vol XIV [air loidhne] ri fhaotainn bho https://stataccscot.edina.ac.uk/static/statacc/dist/viewer/nsa-vol14-Parish_record_for_Lochbroom_in_the_county_of_Ross_and_Cromarty_in_volume_14_of_account_2/ [29 Giblean 2021]
The Globe (1833) “London, Saturday Evening June 22”, 22 Ògmhios 1833, p.4, British Newspaper Archive, [air loidhne] ri fhaotainn bho https://www-britishnewspaperarchive-co-uk.nls.idm.oclc.org/viewer/bl/0001652/18330622/020/0004 [22 Giblean 2021]